Trending Pick'Em-Based Fantasy Sites Right Now

DFS sites are evolving to capture the attention of the millions of DFS fans around the world. These are the trending pick'em-based DFS sites right now!

Matt Brown
By Matt BrownPublished: April 29, 2024
Trending Pick'Em-Based Fantasy Sites Right Now

What you think you know about fantasy sports is constantly evolving, shifting more towards quick, engaging experiences that fit perfectly into our fast-paced world. Every major name in the industry is vying for your attention and wanting to be the biggest name in sports.

With that, Pick'Em-based fantasy sports sites have carved out a significant niche in this area, offering a spin on the mix of sports analysis, real-time decision-making, and instant gratification.

Chances are that you're familiar with these names, but you might not know what they offer.  

What Makes Pick'Em-Based Fantasy Sites Appealing?

Pick'Em-based DFS sites revolve around wagering on the outcomes of specific events within a game rather than the performance of a team or the outcome of the game itself, as you would on traditional platforms such as FanDuel and OwnersBox.

These Pick'Ems are generally limited to specific stats of any given player and differ from online sportsbooks as they don't let you place wagers on a wide swath of picks. Of course, they might offer traditional fantasy as well. 

Take, for example, Underdog Fantasy. You can choose whether Jayson Tatum is going to be higher or lower than 4.5 points in the first quarter or whether he'll be higher or lower than 41.5 points+rebounds+assists. You then add the pick to your entry card and wait to see how Tatum pans out.

It's as simple as that. It's a pick'em with a parlay (you have to choose 2+ picks for Underdog).

This format makes each game intensely personal and thrilling, as fans have multiple opportunities to win based on different aspects of a game.

The Thrill of Real-Time Engagement

One of the key attractions of pick'em-based fantasy sites is the real-time engagement they offer.

Unlike traditional fantasy sports, where decisions are often made days before the actual games, or traditional DFS, where you select an entire lineup, pick'ems keep fans on the edge of their seats throughout the entire match, focusing on a few key players.

This immediate feedback loop enhances the excitement and keeps players coming back for more. We've never met a single pick'em player that wasn't enthusiastic about the game.

A Gateway for Casual Fans

Pick'ems are not just for the seasoned sports fanatics as they might appear.

They offer an accessible entry point for casual fans who might be more interested in individual player performances or specific game moments rather than the broader strategies of team sports.

Not only that, it allows casual players to focus their research on a few key players instead of looking at the entire field.

This simplicity and focus on high-profile players or exciting game moments make pick'em-based games hugely appealing.

Top Trending Pick'Em-Based Fantasy Sites

While there are a good handful of DFS pick'em platforms out there, we've pulled together the top three trending sites to highlight some of the best of the best right now.


PrizePicks stands out in the pick'em-based fantasy sports market with its straightforward and user-friendly interface, making it especially appealing for both newcomers and seasoned players.

A key highlight is their flexible approach to playing; users can select from two to five-player pick'ems in a single entry (think of it as a parlay), increasing the potential payouts as more selections are added. The only downside to this is that it's a bit harder to win out, but you can walk away with a massive stack of cash.

PrizePicks often entices new users with generous welcome bonuses, like matching initial deposits or providing a free entry on sign-up, making the first foray into pick'em-based betting rewarding right out of the gate.

Their broad coverage of sports, including lesser-followed leagues, ensures there's always something for everyone.

PrizePicks Logo

100% Deposit Match

Up to $100


Must be 18+ (19+ in AL and NE, 21+ in AZ, IA, LA, and MA). Concerned with your play? Call 1-800-GAMBLER or visit


ThriveFantasy, though lesser known from some of the bigger players in the game, appeals to both casual and hardcore sports fans by simplifying the often complexity of pick'ems.

What sets them apart is their focus on top-tier athletes and marquee games, reducing the noise and making it easier to engage with the platform. This might not appeal to everyone, but ThriveFantasy is different, and they know it.

ThriveFantasy regularly offers enticing promos, such as deposit bonuses, to enhance the appeal for new users.

On top of that, their quick-payout system adds a bit more satisfaction to winning, ensuring that players feel rewarded immediately.

Their community-driven contests, where users can compete against friends or the public, also add a social element to the experience.

Thrive Fantasy Logo

100% Deposit Match

Up to $250


Must be 18+ (19+ in AL and NE, 21+ in AZ, IA, LA, and MA). Concerned with your play? Call 1-800-GAMBLER or visit

Underdog Fantasy

Underdog Fantasy is quickly becoming a favorite due to its innovative blend of season-long and daily fantasy elements mixed with pick'ems.

The platform offers a unique twist with its 'Best Ball' leagues, where users draft a team at the start of the season, and the best performances each week are automatically selected, simplifying the gameplay and reducing the time you have to be "hands-on."

But we're not here to elaborate on the traditional games, though they're great at them, we're focusing on the pick'ems. Underdog offers no limit on the Pick'Em style games you can play. Whether it's the NBA finals or NFL season opener, you can be sure to find whichever Pick'Em game you're after.

Underdog's bonus structure is robust, offering frequent challenges and leaderboard prizes that keep users engaged throughout the season. Sure, they offer welcome bonuses, but they really shine with the ongoing promotions.

Their easy-to-navigate app complements the exciting game options, making each pick bet a seamless and thrilling experience.

Underdog Fantasy Logo

Special Pick + First Time Deposit Offer

Up to $250 in Bonus Cash


Must be 18+ (19+ in AL and NE, 21+ in AZ, IA, LA, and MA). Concerned with your play? Call 1-800-GAMBLER or visit

The Future of Pick'Em-Based Fantasy Sites

The future looks bright for pick'em-based fantasy sites as they continue to adapt and innovate. Some of these trending sites have even caught the eye of the bigger players, such as DraftKings, who recently released the DraftKings Pick 6, which is a spinoff of the PrizePicks style of play.

With advancements in technology and analytics, these platforms are becoming more sophisticated, offering more detailed and complex pick'ems. We're confident that as the legal situation evolves in various states, we'll see more of these sites popping up and offering innovative ways for you to get into the action.

Matt Brown

Matt Brown

Head of DFS

Matt's deep-rooted enthusiasm for sports betting and daily fantasy sports infuses the EatWatchDraft team with valuable expertise in football, hockey, and baseball. His forward-thinking perspectives are grounded in a solid academic foundation, including a B.S. in Aeronautical Computer Science and an M.S. in Project Management. This combination of sports passion and technical knowledge fuels Matt's innovative input to the platform.